Personal service means just what it says! On March 28, 2008, in United States v. Alpine Land and Reservoir Co., Judge Lloyd D. George reaffirmed that only those 281 individual water right holders who returned their acknowledgement of service must defend the Pyramid Lake Paiute Tribe’s suit challenging the existence of their water rights. The Court’s recent order went on to confirm that those 1300 water right holders who had determined not to mail back an acknowledgment of the Tribe’s mailed service are dismissed.
Importantly, Judge George recognized our continued attempts in the last decade to dismiss the suit for lack of prosecution. Because of those efforts made by Schroeder Law Offices, PC on behalf of its clients, the Court determined that purchasers of lands with challenged water rights who had been served, ie mailed in the acknowledgements, are not bound by the currently filed petition. So the best news might be that of the 281 acknowledged individuals, those that sold the property along with the challenged water rights can also be dismissed.
Unless the Tribe refiles its petition against those dismissed, the number of individuals with challenges to the existence of their water rights is becoming quite small. Good news for Newlands Farmers! The end IS in sight!
