Democrats in the U.S. House of Representatives have taken action to clarify the Clean Water Act following the Sackett decision, introducing new legislation into Congress in October of 2023. The purpose of the “Clean Water Act of 2023” is to counteract the narrow interpretation of the term “navigable waters” set forth in the Supreme Court’s Sackett II. Text of the proposed bill criticizes the Court’s decision for eliminating protection for wetlands that “perform vital functions such as sorting water to help reduce flooding, improving water quality by filtering pollutants, providing critical and important habitats for aquatic and other species, and recharging groundwater that provides drinking water and contributes to downstream flow.”
Importantly, the Act intends to widen the definition of “waters of the United States.” Restrictions, however, do remain as to not extend federal purview to all collections of water. The greatest emphasis is on the definition of “wetlands”, the source of contention in Sackett II. If the Act were to pass, wetlands would now be defined as “those areas that are inundated or saturated by surface or ground water at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstance do support, a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions.” This definition, of course, would circumvent the narrowing of the “water of the United States” that resulted from the Sackett II decision.
While there is little evidence to believe the proposed Act will become law, it is important to be aware of new legal developments that can and will affect water rights throughout the country. Currently, the proposed bill is in the early stages of the legislative process. At this time, the House and Senate have not yet considered the Clean Water Act of 2023.
Additional Resources
For the entire text of the proposed amendment to the Clean Water Act: CWA 2023 Bill Text (house.gov)
For more information on the Sackett Decision that sparked this Act: WOTUS: a Confusing Legacy – Schroeder Law Offices, PC (water-law.com)
